Welcome to Main St Pizza & Ice Cream
At Main St Pizza & Ice Cream, every dish and treat is made with care. Our team hand-cuts vegetables daily, bakes bread in-house, and serves hot New York–style pizza alongside Italian classics. To make your visit even sweeter, we also offer sundaes, Italian ice, milkshakes, banana splits, and classic scoops of ice cream. Enjoy casual dining indoors, outdoor seating, or easy takeout and delivery—always with quick service and a welcoming atmosphere in the heart of Hastings.
Our Menu Highlights
Our kitchen brings guests flavors that feel classic and inviting. Pizzas come out hot, salads are served crisp, and garlic knots arrive golden and cheesy. Each plate is built with fresh prep done daily, giving our food its trusted quality. Whether you’re grabbing takeout, sitting down for lunch, or enjoying dinner outdoors, our menu has favorites that are always ready to share. Order today and enjoy a meal made right here in Hastings.
Sweet Treats to Enjoy
Our menu doesn’t stop with pizza—we also serve a full lineup of ice cream favorites. Choose from creamy scoops, classic sundaes, milkshakes blended to order, banana splits piled high, and refreshing Italian ice. Each treat is made to bring a little extra joy to your visit, whether you’re stopping in with family, cooling off on a warm day, or adding dessert to your meal.
Order with Ease
Choose how you’d like to enjoy your meal with delivery, takeout, or dine-in options. Ordering online is quick, simple, and ensures your pizza or salad is ready when you are. From a family meal at home to a relaxed dinner at our tables, getting your favorites has never been easier.
Mouthwatering Menu
See our pizzas, garlic knots, and fresh salads captured at their best.
Fresh Made Every Day
We believe good food starts with fresh ingredients. That’s why our menu features daily-prepared items like cheesy garlic knots, crisp Greek salad, and pizza made to order. Since opening in 2024, our focus has been on serving honest dishes that bring comfort to the table. With friendly service and quick turnaround, we aim to make every meal feel simple, relaxed, and worth coming back for again and again.
Part of the Hastings Community
More than just a place to grab a slice, our restaurant has become a part of daily life in town. Built on fresh prep and friendly service, it’s a space where families gather, friends share meals, and visitors feel welcome. We’re proud to offer a casual atmosphere where quality and comfort meet. Come by, relax, and enjoy fresh pizza and Italian dishes served with care.
Visit Us in Hastings
Find us at 125 N Main St, Hastings, FL 32145. We’re open every day from 11 am–9 pm, Sunday through Saturday, ready to welcome you. Stop by for dine-in service, enjoy our outdoor seating, or order takeout for a meal on the go. Locals, families, and visitors have made our restaurant a trusted spot for good food and quick service since 2024.
What our guests are saying
The staff was lovely and very sweet to us and our pup (gave her a meatball)! Food was great too; I got a cheese calzone and the Mike's Hot Honey Charred Pepperoni Pizza. So yummy. Great experience.
Lauren B.
Pizza was great. Thin, crispy crust with a good chew. Wings were on point. Outdoor patio seating only. The patio was covered and nice. Order at the window, grab a table, and they bring it out.
Brian C.
We enjoyed a delicious margarita pizza and a fresh Greek salad outside on the deck after a stroll through the St. John Botanical Gardens.
Me M.
Featuring
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-In
Outdoor Seating
High Chairs
Dogs Allowed Outside
Main St Pizza & Ice Cream Rewards
Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online, and redeem your points for free food!
Frequently Asked Questions
What are you known for?
We are known for Meat Lovers Pizza, Meatballs, Milkshake, Margherita Pizza, Birthday Cake Ice Cream, Strawberry Milkshake, Vanilla Ice Cream, Wings, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Caprese, Greek Salad, Dessert, New York Style Pizza, Bruschetta, Fudge, Strawberry Ice Cream, Calzones, Milkshakes, Cannoli, New York Cheesecake, Buffalo Wings, Lasagna, Chocolate Ice Cream, Salads, Garlic Knots, Antipasto Salad, Cookie Dough Ice Cream, Vanilla Milkshake, Brownie Sundae, Spaghetti, Vegetarian Food, Cheese Pizza, Sundae, Italian Food, Stromboli, Calzone, Garlic Bread, Italian Ice, Caesar Salad, Smores, Hawaiian Pizza, Cheesecake, Baked Ziti, Ice Cream, and Strawberry Cheesecake Ice Cream
Where are you located?
We are located in Hastings, FL at 125 N Main St
What areas do you serve?
We serve the following areas: Hastings, Spuds, Federal Point, Byrd, Orange Mills, Bridgeport, Armstrong, Patersonville, Cypress Point, Grandview, Flagler Estates, Yelvington, Gopher Ridge, Elkton, Roy, East Palatka, Riverdale, Bostwick, San Mateo, Pecan.
Our location
